The Writing's On The Wall
Well it is not new that the US has always maintained that the Internet should be a tax free zone as per the US Congress's Tax Freedom Act 1998 (authored by Representative Christopher Cox and Senator Ron Wyden and signed into law on October 21 1998 by then President Clinton) which following expiry continued to be reauthorized and its most recent re-authorization (legal speak for extension) was in October 2007 where this has been extended till 2014. It is unclear whether there will be another extension post 2014. There is a moratorium on new taxes on e-commerce, and the taxing of internet access via the Tax Freedom Act. Whilst the US Congress's Tax Freedom Act 1998 bars federal, state and local governments from taxing Internet access and from imposing discriminatory Internet only taxes such as bit taxes, bandwidth taxes and email taxes, it also bars multiple taxes on electronic commerce. It does not exempt sales made on the Internet from taxation, as these may be taxed at the same state and local sales tax rate as non Internet sales.
New Bill in the House
With the introduction of the US Marketplace Fairness Act in 2013 in both the Senate and the House of Representatives will make for some interesting discussions and lobbying at the Hill. Whilst the Bill in its current form acknowledges the exemptions that are currently in place — the manner in which discussions play out by the manner in which both Senators and Representatives are having reflect a change in atmospheric pressure — which in my mind is significant.
In 1998 the US Senate voted 96-2 to approve the Tax Freedom Act and the mere fact that the new Bill has 28 Co Sponsors and in the House of Reps, there are 47 co sponsors is indicative of either a shift in paradigm or that State coffers are screaming to be filled.
The S.336 Marketplace Fairness Act of 2013 introduced on February 14 day, 2013 and sponsored by US Senator Michael Enzi [R-WY] There are 28 co-sponsors (21D, 6R, 1I).
There is a prognosis that the Bill might not get past the Committee and 0% chance of getting enacted.
The H.R.684: Marketplace Fairness Act of 2013 introduced on February 14, 2013 and sponsored by US Rep. Steve Womack [R-AR3] had 47 cosponsors (25D, 22R). There is a prognosis that it has a 28% chance of getting past the committee and 11% chance of getting enacted.
To Tax or Not to Tax
The term 'electronic commerce' (e commerce) means any transaction conducted over the Internet or through Internet access, comprising the sale, lease, license, offer, or delivery of property, goods, services, or information, whether or not for consideration, and includes the provision of Internet access.
As early as 2000, the problems of tax free e commerce was discussed during the first E Commerce Roundtable meeting in Washington D.C. If e-commerce proceeds untaxed, it would mean that state treasuries would face an eroding tax base. States within the United States of America rely on sales tax for approximately 25-40% of their revenue. As such there is a trade-off or opportunity cost as other taxes may have to increase to make up for the deficit caused by tax-free e-commerce.
The deficit caused by tax free e-commerce means that other taxes may be subjected to increase and also potential funding may be siphoned away from other priority areas. Traditional firms or businesses who do not trade electronically are at a disadvantage as they are forced to collect sales tax at the register. This is why it is sometimes cheaper to purchase a pair of boots online than if you were to walk into a traditional store.
One of the issues that was discussed in the E commerce round table meeting was the widening of the digital divide where people without credit cards or Internet access may be forced to shoulder the burden of sales tax.
E Commerce is blossoming
Global business-to-consumer e-commerce sales will pass the 1 trillion euro ($1.25 trillion) mark by 2013, and the total number of Internet users will increase to approximately 3.5 billion from around 2.2 billion at the end of 2011, according to a new report by the Interactive Media in Retail Group (IMRG), a U.K. online retail trade organization as reported by Internet Retailer dot com . The study estimates that business-to-consumer e-commerce sales in 2011 increased to 690 billion euros ($961 billion), an increase of close to 20% from a year earlier.
According to that study, the US remains the world's largest single market as far as e commerce goes. The same study highlighted that with China's phenomenal growth rates that it is speculated to surpass the United States in this regard shortly.
The US Department of Commerce reported that Total Retail Sales from the fourth quarter of 2012 was estimated at $1,105.8 billion which is an increase of 4% from the third quarter of the same year.
Only Time Will Tell
Whether the US Marketplace Fairness Act will eventually get passed and enacted is something that only time will tell but the timing is certainly interesting.
Written by Salanieta Tamanikaiwaimaro, Director of Pasifika Nexus
Follow CircleID on Twitter